Introduction
The goal of this article is to help photographers who worry about obtaining quality scans.
If you are looking for a comparison to find the cheapest possible scanner, this article is not for you.
First, we’ll look at what tools are available to scan negatives.
Then we’ll compare their performance in terms of scan quality, ease of use and price.
This comparison is based on technical specs but also on my experience as a film photographer.
I’ll try to be as exhaustive as possible.
The different tools
The tools that I will compare are:
- Dedicated film scanners
- Flatbed scanners
- Digital cameras
- Smartphones and workarounds – Why they can’t give qualitative results
Dedicated film scanners
Nikon Coolscan is still the reference but is no longer produced. Plustek Opticfilm, Reflecta and Pacific Image, are the three manufacturers that keep producing dedicated film scanners. They offer the simplest processing method and good image quality.
Flatbed scanners
These are the Epson Perfection and similar models. Practical and easy to use, they allow you to scan multiple negatives in batches.
They can also be used to scan other types of documents.

If you like my photos, you can buy my arwork here: https://electrocroissant.art/en/art-prints/.
Digital camera
You can use your digital camera to scan negatives. However, you will need to purchase a light panel and a tripod to get the best results. There are also more practical devices that can replace these two things.

If you like my photos, you can buy my arwork here: https://electrocroissant.art/en/art-prints/.
Smartphones and workarounds: why they don’t work
You can save money by using your smartphone to digitize your negatives, but I don’t recommend this method for several reasons.
Bad scan quality without a light panel

Using a screen as a light source creates visible pixel patterns in the final image.
Suspending the negative in front of a plain white wall would have given decent results, but it remains a low-quality solution.
I advise against using workarounds. At least, invest in a -good and evenly lit- light panel (€40-50) to achieve better and consistent results.
A smartphone is not performant enough
The tiny sensor of a smartphone remains far from the quality of a good digital camera.
Furthermore, smartphones do not support RAW files, which won’t allow you to edit your scans in depth.
I will no longer mention this method in the rest of the article.
Which option performs best?
Let’s dive into the pros and cons of each of these tools.
We’ll evaluate each option based on:
- Image quality
- Ease of use
- Price
Image quality
Let’s begin with image quality.
ICE for Image Correction and Enhancement
ICE may sound like a generic marketing term but it is actually a real advantage that some flatbed and dedicated film scanner has over a digital camera. Please note that this technology only work for color and black and white films developed using C-41 or E-6 chemistry.
It consists of scanning a film with IR light to isolate and suppress defects such scratch, dust and haze.
With a digital camera, you’ll have to correct these defects manually using image editing software.
Thus, you’ll gain time and quality scan if you use them.
Although, ICE is not perfect.
It can degrade image quality by reducing sharpness and “correcting” parts that are perfectly fine.
If your negative is clean and in good condition, you have no reason to use ICE.
As stated earlier, this technology is only relevant for film developed in C-41 or E-6 chemistry. So if like me you work with classic black and white film, it will be useless to you.
Now let’s compare the others characteristics.
We will look at EFFECTIVE resolution for scanning a 35mm negative, dynamic range and color depth.
Flatbed Scanner
Low effective resolution (for 35mm)
The resolution is 7 megapixels for a high-end flatbed scanner like an Epson V750 Pro [2]. Some of you may fall off their chairs after reading this number, because Epson advertises figures 5 to 10 times higher.
But here’s the thing: beyond 7 megapixels for a 35mm negative, no additional detail will be rendered because of the limitation of the resolving power of scanner’s lens.
It is like using the bottom of a glass bottle on a 48-megapixel camera: yes, you’ll have a 48-megapixel file, but everything will be blurry.
Epson also uses an algorithm to invent pixels and increase resolution.
At this point why not announce 500 megapixels or 1 million? (They are likely restricting themselves solely because of file sizes).
Don’t get me wrong though, not having ugly square pixels but something smoother and blurrier is better if you make a large print. But software like GIMP or Photoshop can also invent pixels in any image. It is not an advantage unique to flatbed scanners.
The same logic applies to color depth. The bottleneck of optical physics is still there. A digital camera will do much better (by far).
So you understand me. Don’t fall for Epson’s marketing. 7 megapixels. 7.
A nuance
The mediocre optical performance of the flatbed scanner tends to be less problematic as the size of the negative increases.
That means that for a medium format negative (four times larger than a 35mm one), the higher effective resolution attainable will be 28 megapixels, which is very reasonable.
Dynamic range
Dynamic range is also an issue. A flatbed scanner has difficulty rendering deep shadows and highlights compared to other types of scanners.
When I switched from a flatbed scanner to a digital camera, I immediately felt the improvement in this area. It was like day and night. There was much more detail and nuance in the scan made with the digital camera.
Dedicated film scanners
There are very cheap specialized 35mm scanners: as expected, their image quality is bad. They are not our subject here.
What I will focus on are more serious options.
With these, image quality is better than with a flatbed scanner. As Epson, all the manufacturers advertises a higher resolution than it actually is. Effective resolution is around 20 megapixels. Plustek is a step behind Reflecta and Pacific Image scanners, but is also a lot cheaper. Dynamic range is also significantly better, but it does not reach the level of a digital camera.
Digital Camera
In terms of image quality, a digital camera is the best you can find. Of course, it depends on what camera you are using.
But an APS-C camera like a 2010 Canon EOS 550D capable of producing RAW files and equipped with a decent macro lens will already give results equivalent to the other two tools. A more recent and higher end camera like a Nikon D850 with a good lens literally offer more than twice the resolution of a scanner, more dynamic range and color depth.
Another advantage of a digital camera is that you can use image stitching to multiply the image resolution. This technique consists of photographing your negative in multiple sections and recombining everything later in post-processing.
Ease of use
Flatbed Scanner
The pros
A flatbed scanner has its advantages:
- It can also be used to scan documents and prints.
- It can digitize multiple film formats and is particularly practical for large format negative.
- You can scan 12 negatives at once and do something else while waiting.
The cons
I personally used an Epson Perfection 4490 scanner and I have some complaints.
Overwhelming and inefficient softwares
The workflow is not as simple as you may think.
Epson’s software is overwhelming. There are a lot of options, and it can be hard to understand what is really useful.
The software also often encountered difficulties in delimiting the frames, particularly when they were dark. So I had to take the time to check and crop it myself before starting the scan.
With a digital camera, you don’t have to go through all of this. You press the shutter button and you have your scan ready to process in GIMP or Photoshop.
file size
A flatbed scanner produces TIFF or DNG files that occupies at least 2 times more disk space than a raw and causes software to run slowly.
Dedicated film scanners
If the quality of image is similar, practicality can vary a lot from one model to another. For example on the Plustek 8200i you have to move the plate manually at each frame. With the Plustek 135i, there is a motor that do that for you, but you still need to reload the negatives every 6 frames. The Reflecta RPS-10M can scan 36 exposures in a row in one hour at 4000 dpi.
Time for scanning one frame vary too. Ease of use is very related to the model you choose and how much money you are willing to put on the table.
Otherwise, the two other options has the ability to scan multiple film formats (35mm, medium format, large format, etc.). With the dedicated film scanner, all you can process is 35mm. It is something you should think about if you plan to use larger format in the future.
Tiff files
Another problem is that you are forced to use a specific software such as vuescan or silverfast, or work with a TIFF file. In all cases, it is easier to work with a RAW file produced by a digital camera.
As said before, a TIFF or DNG file requires at least 2 times more disk space than a raw and causes software to run slowly.
Digital Camera
more preparation time…
Using a digital camera requires more effort and time. You have to set up the tripod, make sure the negative is perfectly flat, expose correctly, manually trigger the shutter for each shot.
But if you have place for a copy stand in your home and are organized, you can speed up the process significantly.
And there also film carrier that screw on the lens like a filter that makes the process a lot easier.
…but time saved later on
The RAW file produced by a digital camera requires less disk space than a TIFF or DNG file.
Reversing the colors and re-framing is done in two minutes; and after that, everything is easy.
Prices
Flatbed Scanner
Epson Perfection 4490 – $60 (second-hand)
Epson V500 – $150-$200 (second-hand)
Epson Perfection V850 Pro – $1000
Dedicated film Scanner
Plustek 8200i – $300
Plustek 135i – $500
Reflecta RPS 10M – $1000
Digital camera
Light pad – $50
Negative carrier -$20 (min)
Tripod – $50
Camera – $100 (min)
Macro Lens – $100 (min)
Total = $220 (min)
For the Epson Perfection scanners, be aware that the technology has not really evolved through the recent decade(s?). So paying 10 times more for a recent model may not be the smarter financial option.
Same applies for dedicated scanners. A 20 years old Nikon Coolscan 9000 ED is still the reference today.1
If you already have a digital camera, it is obviously the cheaper and best value for money option.
But overall, the price ranges are the same. I could not find a significantly cheaper option.
Conclusion: Digital Camera for every format or Flatbed Scanner beyond medium format
I think you got my point: scanning with a digital camera is the best option. But, there a few nuances.
Digital camera is the best option
If you want to digitize 35mm film, do it with a digital camera. It the tool that will give you the best image quality.
It is more demanding than simply put your negatives in a flatbed scanner, but it’s worth the effort.
And if like me you don’t need all the features proposed by the other type of scanners (ICE and others), you’ll be very with the simplicity of ending up with a raw file. But also save space on your disk drive.
Here is a complete tutorial on how to scan your negatives using a digital camera: https://electrocroissant.art/en/digitizing-your-negatives-with-a-digital-camera/.
You can consider a flatbed scanner beyond medium format (simple and decent scan quality)
However, if you are into medium or large format, the weaknesses of the flatbed scanner in terms of image quality become less problematic.
Scan quality will be close (medium format) or superior (large format) to a digital camera –if you don’t do image stitching with your digital camera. And it will be a less tedious task.
Personally, if I worked with large format, I would definitely consider using a flatbed scanner. Doing image stitching with a digital camera is a big effort, and unless you plan to do a 2 meter wide print, you don’t need a file of 200 megapixels.
Dedicated film scanner: a compromise between quality and practicality
As for dedicated film scanners, the only model that could convince me to leave my digital camera is the Reflecta RPS 10M because it can scan a roll in a row.
For the others, practicality and gain of time compared to a digital camera is marginal. And a digital camera offers better scan quality.
Final Advice
The truth is flatbed scanners and dedicated film scanners has ceased to evolved in the last two decades. It even go back on some points.
During these 20 years, digital camera sensors gain more definition. Software such as Photoshop became more capable and made scanner’s technology such as infrared cleaning redondant.
Nowadays, digital camera scanning has largely surpassed scanners. My Nikon D850 is capable of giving a 48MP scan. The best scanner available is around 20MP.
A scanner could be interesting if you plan to
For me, unless you have these particular needs, using a scanner is an anachronism.
So my final advice to a photographer that hesitate is to scan with digital camera. Setting up a light panel and a tripod takes five minutes or you can use one those device if you want to go faster.
















Leave a Reply